Table 2

Main outcomes reported in the included studies

AuthorYearOpen (n)MIS (n)Relapse openRelapse MISRelapse rate openRelapse rate MISDefinition OS/PFSDFS openD


DFS MIS
Death openDeath MISOS openOS MIS
Chen C et al 22 202092692637444.0%4.8%Not provided5 year 94.9%5 year 92.6%22185 year 96.6%5 year 96.3%
Chen X et al 21 20201961295112.6%8.5%Not provided5 year 97.7%5 year 90.4%345 year 99.4%5 year 96.9%
Chiva et al 20 202016012815179.4%13.3%From surgeryHR 1.63 (95% CI 0.79 to 3.40) favor open58HR 2.77 (0.91 to 8.47) favor open
Hu et al 16 2020147147956.1%3.4%From surgery5 year 94.3%5 year 97.3%225 year 97.6%5 year 99.3%
Kim et al 15 201912212211109.0%8.2%From diagnosis3 year 93.1%3 year 90%925 year 96.4%5 year 98.6%
Nam et al 13 2012173162582.9%4.9%From surgery5 year 97.4%5 year 94.2%35n/an/a
Paik et al 12 201918662160.5%9.7%From surgeryHR 12.987 (1.45 to 116.24) favor open01n/an/a
Rodriguez et al 24 2021492486n/an/an/an/aFrom surgeryHR 1.44 (0.85 to 2.45)n/an/aHR 2.44 (1.05 to 5.67)
Uppal et al 10 2020821822162.4%8.8%From surgeryaHR:6.31 (1.24 to 31.9) favor openn/an/an/an/a
Yang et al 11 20205750n/an/an/an/aFrom surgeryHR 1.695 (0.29 to 9.77)n/an/aHR 2.69 (0.48 to 15.07)
  • aHR, adjusted hazard ratio; DFS, disease-free survival; MIS, minimally invasive surgery; n/a, not available; OS, overall survival; PFS, progression-free survival.