Table 2

Studies investigating the molecular and/or immunological mechanisms during mammary gland involution in PPBC in humans

Human
Research subject and methods Findings Ref
I. Studies investigating ECM remodeling and wound-healing-like programs
  • FISH analysis of collagen deposition and orientation in the breast tissue of 3 np and 3 PPBC women.

  • Analysis of 11 publicly available microarray datasets of 345 cases≤45 years that relapsed.

  • Increased collagen deposition in PPBC.

  • Increased COL1A1 and COX-2 expression that correlated with decreased relapse-free survival.

Lyons30
2011
  • Analysis of adjacent normal breast tissue from 183 premenopausal women aged 20 to 45 years, grouped by reproductive categories.

  • Stain for lobular area, lobular composition, apoptosis, and immune cell infiltration.

  • Increased breast epithelial area in pregnancy and lactation.

  • Reduced mammary epithelial area in involution <12 months.

  • Involution is characterized by wound-healing-like tissue remodeling programs that occurs within a narrow time frame (18 months).

Jindal37 *
2014
II. Studies investigating lymphangiogenesis
  • Analysis of 38 postpartum and 190 np breast cancer patients≤45 years.

  • Analysis of lymphatic vessel density in normal adjacent and breast tumor tissue measured by D2−40+vessel count.

  • Increased lymph node positivity in PPBC patients. No difference in HER-2 or triple-negative cases.

  • Increased lymphatic vessel density and tumor cell invasion of lymphatics in PPBC patients.

Lyons26
2014
  • Analysis of SEMA7A in normal breast tissue from biopsy by IHC.

  • Kaplan–Meier analysis of SEMA7A, PDPN, and CD68 expression in >600 breast cancers, as well as ovarian, lung, and gastric cancer.

  • Increased expression of SEMA7A in breast tissue from women>5 years involuting.

  • Decreased distant metastasis-free survival when SEMA7A, PDPN,and CD68 were co-expressed.

Elder38
2018
III. Studies investigating immune cell infiltration
  • Analysis of normal breast tissue from 32 postpartum (up to 10y) and 20 np women aged 18 to 45 years.

  • LCM, RNA expression, and RT-PCR of 64 selected genes associated with involution.

  • Upregulated inflammation-associated genes in postpartum women.

  • Reduced expression of ESR1, PGR, HER2, and higher expression of ESR2 in postpartum women. 14 of 64 genes from RT-PCR were differentially regulated.

Asztalos23 *
2010
  • Analysis of normal and tumor tissue from 6 np, 9 pregnant, 11 lactating, 8 involuting, and 10 regressed women aged ≤45 years.

  • IHC, IF, imaging of CD68, CSF-1R, and F4/80.

  • Increased macrophage number during involution that exhibited an M2-phenotype with expression of IL-4 and IL-13.

O’Brien45
2010
  • Analysis of tumor tissue from 17 recent pregnant, 17 distant pregnant, and 19 np breast cancer patients aged 18 to 45 years.

  • RT-PCR, IHC,and image analysis.

  • Different gene expression pattern (8-gene signature) in breast cancers detected in PPBC diagnosed up to 10 years after delivery, mainly attributable to the TNBC subgroup.

Asztalos47 *
2015
  • Analysis of tumor tissue from 50 postpartum and 7 np breast cancer patients, grouped by reproductive categories.

  • IHC of IL-10 and FoxP3.

  • Increased infiltration of IL-10 +and FoxP3 +immune cells in post-lactational human breast tissue suggestive of immunosuppressive microenvironment.

Martinson44
2015
  • Analysis of tumor tissue from 3 postpartum patients and 3 np breast cancer patients.

  • Multiplex analysis and TCGA RNAseq analysis

  • Increased PD-L1 expression and PD-L1 T-cells in postpartum patients.

  • Observed co-expression of immune inhibitory PD-L1, PDPN,and CD68 in breast cancer TCGA patients.

Tamburini62
2019
  • *Studies exclusively focusing on human breast tissue.

  • ECM, extracellular matrix; IF, immunofluorescence; IHC, immunohistochemistry; np, nulliparous; PPBC, postpartum breast cancer; RT-PCR, real-time PCR.