Article Text

Download PDFPDF

874 Uptake of population based BRCA-testing across Jewish denominations and affect of cultural and religious factors: a cohort study
  1. D Reisel1,
  2. M Burnell2,
  3. L Side3,
  4. K Loggenberg1,
  5. S Gessler1,
  6. R Desai1,
  7. S Sanderson4,
  8. A Brady5,
  9. H Dorkins6,
  10. Y Wallis7,
  11. C Jacobs8,
  12. R Legood9,
  13. U Beller10,
  14. I Tomlinson11,
  15. U Menon2,
  16. I Jacobs12 and
  17. R Manchanda9,13
  1. 1University College London, Institute for Women’s Health, UK
  2. 2University College London, MRC Clinical Trials Unit, London, UK
  3. 3University Hospital Southampton NHS Foundation Trust, Clinical Genetics, UK
  4. 4University College London, Behavioral Sciences Unit, Dept Epidemiology and Public Health, London, UK
  5. 5Northwick Park Hospital, North West Thames Regional Genetics Service, UK
  6. 6University of Oxford, St Peter’s College, UK
  7. 7Birmingham Women’s Hospital, West Midlands Regional Genetics Laboratory, UK
  8. 8University of Technology Sydney, Ultimo, Australia
  9. 9London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, Health Services Research and Policy, London, UK
  10. 10Shaare Zedek Medical Center, Jerusalem, Israel
  11. 11University of Birmingham, UK
  12. 12UNSW Sydney, Sydney, Australia
  13. 13Queen Mary University of London, Centre for Cancer Prevention, London, UK


Introduction/Background*Population-based BRCA-testing in the Ashkenazi Jewish (AJ) population is feasible, acceptable, reduces anxiety, identifies more BRCA-carriers and is cost-effective. The Jewish population is the first population for whom unselected population testing is now being implemented with Israel recently adopted this into national policy. Guideline change is being advocated in the UK and by others too. It is unknown whether BRCA-testing differs across Jewish denominational affiliations and religious or cultural outlook. We evaluate the association of Jewish cultural and religious identity and denominational affiliation with interest-in, intention-to undertake and uptake-of population-based BRCA-testing

Design Cohort-study set within recruitment to GCaPPS-trial (ISRCTN73338115).

AJ men and women, >18years, from London, self-referred, and attended recruitment clinics(clusters) for pre-test counselling. Subsequently consenting individuals underwent BRCA-testing. Mina oucome measures were: Interest, intention, uptake-of BRCA-testing. Participants self-identified to one Jewish denomination: Conservative/Liberal/Reform/Traditional/Orthodox/Unaffiliated. Validated scales measured Jewish Cultural-Identity (JI) and Jewish Religious-identity (JR). 4-item Likert-scales analysed initial ‘interest’ and ‘intention-to-test’ pre-counselling. Item-Response-Theory and graded-response-models, modelled responses to JI and JR scales. Ordered/multinomial logistic regression modelling evaluated association of JI-scale, JR-scale and Jewish Denominational affiliation on interest, intention and uptake-of BRCA-testing.

Result(s)*935 AJ women/men of mean-age=53.8 (S.D=15.02) years, received pre-test education and counselling through 256 recruitment clinic clusters (mean cluster size=3.64). Denominational affiliations included Conservative/Masorti=91(10.2%); Liberal=82(9.2%), Reform=135(15.1%), Traditional=212(23.7%), Orthodox=239(26.7%); and Unaffiliated/Non-practising=135(15.1%). Overall BRCA-testing uptake was 88%. Pre-counselling 96% expressed interest and 60% intention-to test. JI and JR scores were highest for Orthodox, followed by Conservative/Masorti, Traditional, Reform, Liberal and Unaffiliated Jewish denominations. Regression modelling showed no significant association between overall Jewish Cultural or Religious Identity with either interest, intention or uptake-of BRCA-testing. Interest, intention and uptake of BRCA-testing was not significantly associated with denominational affiliation.

Conclusion*Jewish religious/cultural identity and denominational affiliation do not appear to influence interest, intention or uptake of population-based BRCA-testing. BRCA-testing was robust across all Jewish denominations.

Statistics from

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.